June 2021: Midnight Gardens - Revision history

Sunflash: Adding Category tag

2023-01-26T17:51:27Z

Adding Category tag

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:51, 26 January 2023
Line 197:		Line 197:

	<!-- slurmp had a review here but mediawiki is allergic to it -->		<!-- slurmp had a review here but mediawiki is allergic to it -->

			[[Category:Area of the Month]]

Admin at 02:23, 20 October 2022

2022-10-20T02:23:12Z

Show changes

Admin at 02:22, 20 October 2022

2022-10-20T02:22:46Z

Show changes

Admin at 02:21, 20 October 2022

2022-10-20T02:21:40Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:21, 19 October 2022
Line 199:		Line 199:

	----		----
			'''Player: Slurmp'''

Admin at 02:21, 20 October 2022

2022-10-20T02:21:19Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:21, 19 October 2022
Line 197:		Line 197:

	<!-- a -->		<!-- a -->

			----

Admin at 02:21, 20 October 2022

2022-10-20T02:21:13Z

Show changes

Admin at 02:18, 20 October 2022

2022-10-20T02:18:38Z

Show changes

Admin at 02:17, 20 October 2022

2022-10-20T02:17:16Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:17, 19 October 2022
Line 130:		Line 130:

	Elaborate garden connects to a forest. Sure, I have no trouble seeing it. Lots of plants either way, one is just more cultivated.		Elaborate garden connects to a forest. Sure, I have no trouble seeing it. Lots of plants either way, one is just more cultivated.

			----




			'''Player: Ryrol (Thief 13/1 remort at time of review)'''

			'''Review Date(s): JUNE 18 2021'''

			'''Descriptions: 7/10'''


			I enjoy the room descriptions in this area. The verbiage is varied, the rooms feel distinct from one another, and for a newer player to MUDs I think there are a few tricks they can learn from navigating the area. The NPCs feel distinct, despite most of the ones having information are not very distinguishing by short description. Unfortunately so far I think the flavor text is a bit lacking (or hard to find), I tend to read rooms and look for keywords, and I didn't really find things at all, especially where I really would think there should be (possibly because of quests there are things in the room description that become more noticeable later, but truthfully coming in and looking as a observer nothing really stood out). As a person who specifically enjoys finding the "little touches" in a room, that was probably the biggest downside (for me) in this area so far.

			It's nice there is both a food and water source in the area, it does help give it a "lived in" feel, however with the exception of wandering enemies, things do feel a little static. There are also some benches, and while I'm not sure if they give a resting bonus, they do help give some flair. Without strong extra descs, I would hope there would at least a few more objects to look at, but have no complaints about the ones currently on display.

			I think the enemies are interesting, and there are a few different styles of enemy on display here that not make combat interesting. At the moment I'm not getting any alignment changes from any kills, which I feel could be worked on. I will say some areas feel like they are far more dense than others, which would be fine except most of the mobiles are grouped in one area together, and as stated before, not much to differentiate them.


			'''Balance: N/A'''


			I am underleveled for the area, so I will not give it a score, but I will make a few comments on the combat.

			As mentioned before, there are a few different mob combat styles on display here (poisoners, stealers, strong melee, casters) so I think a player or group of players will find something they like in the area at one level range or another. There is (more or less) a clear separation of the area between the higher and lower level mobs, and most don't seem aggressive so you can move freely to the places you'd like.

			I think some people would not like some of the mobs because of their combat or out of combat effects, but personally I find this to be a positive. I enjoy varied and challenging combat, so the less a mob just plain auto attacks, the happier I am. Especially in an area where mobs are not aggressive or link, I don't mind a more challenging battle. That being said, I think someone looking for easier or more straightforward combat will avoid this place.


			'''Attractions: 4/10'''


			I feel there are a few reasons players would come to this area, but I think in general most coming for a '''specific''' reason will feel underwhelmed.

			Someone coming for quests may get frustrated if they are newer to MUDs. As mentioned in another review, I feel the ability to continue the quest relies on aggressive tactics, or an unforeseen method. This is an issue with many quests at the moment, where deductive and inductive reasoning are not helpful, and one must turn to outside sources or nonsensical actions to solve a quest. If it wasn't for one little hiccup, I would have really enjoyed the only quest in the area.


			I think someone could level here, but I don't think someone who is looking to streamline the leveling process will. Considering it is based in an area for more seasoned players (closer to Viorar), many players are set in what they want for mobs, and this isn't it. As I mentioned before, I don't think the area is bad for leveling, but considering only one quest and the style of mobs, experience grinders won't visit.

			The gold and loot seem fine for the area, maybe a bit more powerful for someone (it seems a lot of the gear will become available more for when you leave the area, which is helpful but kills the vibe of finding something and being able to try it out right away). Once again, I don't think someone will come here specifically for the loot, but I think someone can find some decent things coming here.

			There weren't any shops I could find in the area.

			To recap:

			- I think it lacks flavor for exploring players

			- It lacks an overall grindable mob for xp players

			- It lacks strong loot for optimized players

			- It lacks quests for questing players

			It saddens me, because I think Midnight Gardens wanted to be all of these things, but fell short. I think a player could come here and still find fun, but I don't think it will be recommended by others. There are better quests, better mobs, better loot, and a better feel elsewhere, and even while none of those are strong enough to hold up on their own, the overall experience feels lacking as well. I personally don't think I'd come back unless it would be to quickly do the quest again and be on my way.


			'''Connections: 6/10 '''


			The area is where it says it is, and for newer players it's clearly highlighted in both the map and atlas. I think the process of getting there might be a little... strained the first time, but it is not quest blocked nor is needlessly difficult to find.

			There is only one real connection, which... it is a hedge maze, so I can't fault it too much. I suppose I'm of the mind I think the connection could be better, or maybe just a little more visible, but I don't have a clear solution as to how.

			If the connection remained unchanged, I don't think I would be too bothered, especially compared to the other issues within the area.

Admin at 02:16, 20 October 2022

2022-10-20T02:16:59Z

@@ Line 82: / Line 82: @@
 I was completely prepared to totally hate my life here because navigating non-linear mazes is not one of my strong points but weirdly, I enjoyed it a lot more than I expected! If you're unobservant as hell like me, drawing a map and finding a way to mark the rooms you've been in is extremely helpful.
-It would not be the worst place to get experience, but it's not the best. There is at least one unique item that I can see being useful for a long time after you outlevel most of the benefits of the zone.
+It would not be the wor----
 The quest list does feel a bit short, with only one quest in the area that can be completed. It is, however, a slightly longer quest that could end up taking a very long time depending on how lost you get or how hard the hints are for you to piece together.

Admin at 02:16, 20 October 2022

2022-10-20T02:16:45Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:16, 19 October 2022
Line 45:		Line 45:
	How easily and well does this area connect to its nearby areas?		How easily and well does this area connect to its nearby areas?
	Does it make sense thematically to be connected to the areas it is?		Does it make sense thematically to be connected to the areas it is?

			----

			'''Player: Coeurl, as Remi (Geomancer/15-18)''' --TOKEN'D

			'''Review Date(s): 5/26-5/29'''

			'''Descriptions: 7/10'''

			The descriptions paint a good picture of the area. The amount of extra descriptions I spotted seemed to be about right.

			There are actually several rooms with a stream or fountain that cannot be drunk from but there is a room with a functioning fountain so it's probably okay that every single room isn't a source of water.

			There are a couple of areas with repeating descriptions but the POINT of those areas is to be mazelike and difficult to navigate so this is not a negative.

			There is a gazebo in one room with an extra description with no way to interact with. This isn't NECESSARILY a bad thing but I was a little disappointed there wasn't a little more to check out there. Another room has some statues I wanted to get a closer look at but had no extra descs. This is really nitpicking though.

			You can attack the featured quest NPC (if you are some kind of a monster) and they do not have a special reaction or seem to have any mprogs. Seems like this should either be fixed or they should not be attackable.

			Every mob that I talked to responded, which I like to see.


			'''Balance: 8/10'''

			The area struck me as quite well tuned overall. It's incredibly annoying that engaging a Crawler is basically GUARANTEED Blight and you'll watch a ton of your HP tick away after combat ends, but some mobs can just be annoying. As a vanilla geomancer I was challenged enough that I needed to rest reasonably often but didn't find anything that I absolutely COULD NOT kill.

			The Porobin Hoods are going to be a little bit rough if you come there on the low end (it's a level 16-25 zone, and they're level 21) and they're harder to completely ignore because they can steal from you, but at least you can somewhat prepare for that because banks exist. Other than Crawlers they were probably the most frustrating to deal with because they hit fairly hard and money you pick up in the area isn't safe.

			In fact, the major boss of the area was incredibly challenging, but still possible to solo. I was able to beat it on my own, but it required spamming the pumpkin pombs that I had collected in the area and I was in the single digits in HP. That strikes me as about perfect in terms of difficulty level. As a solo character I would not have been able to win if I had gone in any less prepared.

			There's a light you can obtain in the area that's thematically cool, but it has a negligible bonus and doesn't last for very long so it's a little disappointing. There are a couple of items that fill rarer equipment slots that are cool, though.


			'''Attractions: 8/10'''

			I was completely prepared to totally hate my life here because navigating non-linear mazes is not one of my strong points but weirdly, I enjoyed it a lot more than I expected! If you're unobservant as hell like me, drawing a map and finding a way to mark the rooms you've been in is extremely helpful.

			It would not be the worst place to get experience, but it's not the best. There is at least one unique item that I can see being useful for a long time after you outlevel most of the benefits of the zone.

			The quest list does feel a bit short, with only one quest in the area that can be completed. It is, however, a slightly longer quest that could end up taking a very long time depending on how lost you get or how hard the hints are for you to piece together.

			Also, being as vague as possible to avoid qinfo, there is an item in the area that you will need to proceed if you didn't come prepared. I couldn't figure out a way to obtain the item without being a murderhobo, and I think I would have liked a less violent method to procure the item, given that it came from an a peaceful NPC. This could be another quest in the area, maybe?

			I found no shops in the area.


			'''Connections: 10/10 '''

			Elaborate garden connects to a forest. Sure, I have no trouble seeing it. Lots of plants either way, one is just more cultivated.